AfterSell App Review: Features, Pros & Cons for Shopify

Customer reviews: AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell

AfterSell is a Shopify app designed to help merchants increase revenue through post-purchase upsells, order bumps, and personalized offers. This review compiles verified user experiences, pros, cons, and pricing details to help you decide if it fits your store's needs.

Reviews (663)

Overall rating

4.8

5

383
4

10
3

1
2

6
1

15

What Merchants Think

"AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell" enjoys generally positive feedback from merchants. Many praise its intuitive interface, customization options, and seamless integration with Shopify, which significantly enhances average order value (AOV). However, some users have faced issues with app functionality or pricing. Overall, the app is highly recommended for boosting sales and improving customer experience post-purchase.

Key Strengths

Exceptional customer service with responsive and helpful support representatives like Patti, Jacinda, Dom, and Lillian.
Intuitive and easy-to-navigate user interface.
Effective at increasing revenue and boosting AOV through post-purchase upsell and cross-sell offers.
Extensive customization options that allow tailored upsell strategies.
Seamless integration with existing Shopify stores.
Useful resources and tutorials provided by support for easy setup and troubleshooting.

Common Concerns

Complaints about the app's pricing model, which charges based on total orders, not just orders with upsells.
Technical issues like updates requiring re-setup and potential bugs with payment integrations.
Communication challenges about app breaking due to new Shopify checkout changes and slow responses from customer service at times.
Frustration with the learning curve and the need for strategic thinking when setting up upsell funnels.

Final Thoughts

"AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell" is a robust tool for merchants looking to maximize their Shopify store's sales through effective upsell strategies. It is particularly lauded for its exceptional customer service and ease of use, making it a top choice for many. Despite some challenges related to pricing and occasional bugs, its strengths greatly outweigh its weaknesses, making it a valuable addition for enhancing post-purchase processes.

Vape360

Jun 10, 2025 on Shopify

It's pretty straight forward with some useful features. It's a little convoluted with creating, activating, and then activating again inside the theme, but it works. The checkout options are nice. They could use some more customization and freedom when it comes to recommendations, but it's not bad at all. The biggest issue is features being activated that can't be deactivated because of their paywall. For example, when integrating the app, you follow the recommended steps provided by the app. Since it's your first time using it, you go by what the developer recommends. Part of that integration is selecting Aftersell in your post-purchase page. What you don't know is that the Post-Purchase Funnels are behind a paywall, so when you finish the trial and stick with just the checkout plan, you cannot access post-purchase funnels to turn them off. Now, I have orders that are set to "hold" before fulfillment because of a setting I can't turn off. Removing Aftersell from post-purchase page hopefully stops this, but is still injecting code into my theme that's not being used - creating code bloat. Even customer service can't deactivate them - they just tell you to remove it from post-purchase in checkout settings. Feels a little weird and sketchy that Aftersell themselves can't turn it off permanently without me paying. I'll probably move on to another checkout app. I've used a large amount of apps on Shopify and have never seen a reverse pay wall at the expense of the user.

SeasonTech

Jun 09, 2025 on Shopify

Changed the cost without notice. $9 > $34.99 It was a good app, but there are ones out there just as good, if not better.

The Pod Company

Apr 22, 2025 on Shopify

Product is good, support service is terrible

Sybotanica

Jan 30, 2025 on Shopify

No communication about the app literally being broken by the new Shopify checkout. Lost revenue and now it doesn't even work.

Invisible Height

Apr 09, 2024 on Shopify

I'm going from 5 stars to 2 stars because it never worked, in 3 days the upsells were only displayed for 1 customer and on top of that, the pixel didn't even detect this sale. Customer service, apart from Patti, is extremely slow and bland... None of my requests, however simple, were resolved and these 3 days of using this app were enough to reduce my ROAS from 2.11 to 1.32... and I really regret having installed this app!

Aloe Paris

Mar 20, 2024 on Shopify

Overall, the application is "ok". If I put 2 stars it's because the application crashes constantly and hours of work on the funnels are lost for NO REASON!