Smile vs Joy: Best Loyalty Programs for Shopify

Name: Joy Rewards &amp; Loyalty Program
Brand: Joy Loyalty (by Avada)

If you're looking to enhance customer loyalty through your Shopify store, selecting the right app for your loyalty rewards program is crucial. In this insightful comparison, we delve into the features, pricing, integrations, and overall effectiveness of two popular options: Smile Loyalty & Rewards Program and Joy: Rewards & Loyalty Program. Understanding the nuances between these platforms will empower you to make an informed decision, optimizing the engagement and retention strategy of your online store. Whether you're a small business owner or a seasoned e-commerce professional, this guide will help you choose the ideal loyalty program to boost customer satisfaction and drive continued growth.

Smile: Loyalty Rewards Program

Loyalty program - points, rewards, referrals, & VIP

Joy Rewards & Loyalty Program

Loyalty & Rewards Program with VIP Tiers, POS & Loyalty Page

Smile: Loyalty Rewards Program

Loyalty program - points, rewards, referrals, & VIP

Joy Rewards & Loyalty Program

Loyalty & Rewards Program with VIP Tiers, POS & Loyalty Page

Overview

What is Smile: Loyalty Rewards Program?

Smile Loyalty & Rewards is a Shopify app designed to help businesses create customizable loyalty programs, referral campaigns, and VIP tiers to engage customers and drive repeat sales.

Key Strengths:

Highly customizable rewards and points system
Seamless integration with Shopify stores
Built-in referral program features

What is Joy Rewards & Loyalty Program?

Joy Rewards & Loyalty Program is a Shopify app focused on increasing customer engagement through points, discounts, and referral incentives. It emphasizes simplicity and automation.

Key Strengths:

Automated reward workflows
Gamified customer experience
Seamless Shopify integration

Rating

6,977 Reviews

9.5

2,052 Reviews

9.3

Pricing

Install App More info

Features

App integrations
Multi-language support
Coupons and discounts
Vip tiers
Membership perks
Referral programs
Engagement nudges
Customizable rewards
Guest shopper points
Program translation

App integrations
Discount stacking
Automated notifications
Loyalty page generator
Pos integration
Loyalty programs setup
Vip tiers management
Rewards customization

Screenshots

+ 5 more

+ 4 more

Your request is being processed and will be delivered shortly. If you do not receive an email from Taranker within the next 5 minutes, please check your spam folder and mark it as "Not Spam" to ensure future emails reach your inbox.

Pros

No coding required for setup
Easy integration with various apps
Highly customizable to match brand aesthetics
Supports multiple languages
Offers various types of rewards and programs
Comprehensive support from a responsive team
Positive feedback on customer service and support
Effective at boosting sales and brand loyalty
Good documentation available
Free plan available that works well for some users

Easy to set up loyalty programs, VIP tiers, and rewards
Compatible with POS systems for a seamless in-store and online experience
Automated email notifications and app integrations
Offers a wide variety of reward and discount types
Manageable customer tiers, points, and missions with data export/import options
Positive customer service experiences repeatedly praised in reviews
Useful customer service chat feature that provides immediate support
Highly customizable with options for badges, cash back, coupons, and more

Cons

High cost for small businesses
Some features locked behind higher-tier plans
Issues with translating certain elements fully
Complaints about slow response time for support
No live chat support for quick assistance
Difficulty in setup for some users
Not available for Shopify's Starter Pack users

Some features are marked as 'Coming Soon' and have not been added for a long time
Issues with Klaviyo API integration that have not been resolved, affecting email marketing campaigns
Limited functionality with the referral program – cannot offer points for referrals, only discounts
Point balance function does not work with Shopify New account type
Some users feel the app's abilities are minimal for a rewards program
Coupons under the Reward list code do not show the actual amount of the coupon

Launched

Dec 01, 2014

Jun 27, 2021

Developer

Built by Smile.io

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.8

Reviews:

6,977

Built by Joy Loyalty (by Avada)

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.9

Reviews:

2,052

Make Your Choice

Install App More info View alternatives

Smile vs Joy: Best Loyalty Programs for Shopify

Smile: Loyalty Rewards Program

Joy Rewards & Loyalty Program

Smile: Loyalty Rewards Program