S Loyalty vs Oneloyalty: Shopify Loyalty Apps Compared

Name: OneLoyalty: Loyalty &amp; Rewards
Brand: OneCommerce.io

When it comes to enhancing customer engagement and boosting sales on your Shopify store, selecting the right loyalty rewards and referral program is crucial. In this comparison, we delve into two popular Shopify apps: S Loyalty Rewards & Referrals and OneLoyalty Loyalty & Rewards. By examining their features, ease of integration, pricing structures, and user feedback, this guide is designed to help you determine which app aligns best with your business goals. Whether you are new to Shopify or looking to optimize your existing store, our insights will assist you in choosing the most effective loyalty solution to enrich customer experiences and drive sustained growth.

S Loyalty: Rewards & Referrals

Reward customers, build loyalty and grow referral sales.

OneLoyalty: Loyalty & Rewards

Drive repeat purchase rate with powerful loyalty & rewards

S Loyalty: Rewards & Referrals

Reward customers, build loyalty and grow referral sales.

OneLoyalty: Loyalty & Rewards

Drive repeat purchase rate with powerful loyalty & rewards

Rating

277 Reviews

9.1

114 Reviews

7.7

Pricing

Install App More info

Features

Free shipping
Birthday rewards
Reward customers
Data export
Thank you messages
Build loyalty
Welcome bonuses
Referral sales
Personalized bonuses
Points campaigns
Customer exclusion
Order fulfillment points
Pay with points
Holiday bonuses
Special points events
Purchase history tracking
Scheduled expirations

Referral programs
Earn points activities
Reward options
Custom programs
Membership rewards
Points expiration
Loyalty widget

Screenshots

+ 3 more

+ 8 more

Your request is being processed and will be delivered shortly. If you do not receive an email from Taranker within the next 5 minutes, please check your spam folder and mark it as "Not Spam" to ensure future emails reach your inbox.

Pros

Helps build customer loyalty and grow store sales
Offers rewards, personalized bonuses, and points-based campaigns
Engages customers with personalized rewards and custom campaigns
Handles customer exclusions and reward point details automatically
Allows for “Pay with Points”, “Free Shipping”, or percentage and fixed amount rewards
Provides holiday bonuses, birthday rewards, special points events, and extra point campaigns
Includes personalized features like “Welcome” and “Birthday” bonuses and “Thank You” messages
Tracks customer purchasing and point redemption history, with data export options
Automation features for scheduling expiration dates for unused reward points or discount codes

Exceptional customer service and support, frequently praised by users
User interface is intuitive and clean, making it easy to navigate
Wide range of features including rewards for purchases and interactions, customizable loyalty widgets, and referral programs
Highly responsive support team, often mentioned by name (eg, Ellie, Rosie, Emily)
Smooth performance with no noticeable bugs or crashes reported
Easy and quick setup process, even for those with minimal technical skills
Free to use while offering comprehensive and customizable features
Encourages valuable customer actions like follow on social media and returning for repeat purchases
Helps drive repeat purchases and customer retention with various rewards such as discounts, free shipping, and gift options

Cons

Some users experienced issues with the app loading and widgets not displaying properly
Concerns about reliability and dependence on third-party integrations, especially regarding the potential impact on frontend customer experience
App might not be ideal for long-term use if developers decide to impose a paid plan or discontinue the free version
Lack of built-in features within Shopify, requiring reliance on the app for reward solutions

Launched

Nov 08, 2012

Apr 10, 2024

Developer

Built by S Loyalty

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.6

Reviews:

277

Built by OneCommerce.io

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.7

Reviews:

3,494

Make Your Choice

Install App More info View alternatives

Related blog

12 Best Shopify Loyalty and Reward Apps in 2025

S Loyalty vs Oneloyalty: Shopify Loyalty Apps Compared

S Loyalty: Rewards & Referrals

OneLoyalty: Loyalty & Rewards

S Loyalty: Rewards & Referrals