Compare Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping vs ShipInsure Shipping Protection

Name: ShipInsure Shipping Protection
Brand: ShipInsure

Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping

Save money on USPS and UPS with an easy-to-use app

ShipInsure Shipping Protection

Give customers the option for a protected checkout experience

Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping

Save money on USPS and UPS with an easy-to-use app

ShipInsure Shipping Protection

Give customers the option for a protected checkout experience

Overview

What is Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping?

Pirate Ship CheapArr Shipping is a Shopify app that helps merchants access discounted USPS and UPS shipping rates. It simplifies label printing and order fulfillment.

Key Strengths:

Discounted USPS and UPS rates
Easy label printing
No monthly fees

What is ShipInsure Shipping Protection?

ShipInsure Shipping Protection offers comprehensive coverage for Shopify merchants, protecting against lost, damaged, or delayed shipments with a straightforward claims process.

Key Strengths:

Simple flat-rate pricing per order
Quick claims approval (often within 48 hours)
No deductibles or hidden fees

Rating

59 Reviews

1.9

38 Reviews

8.6

Pricing

Install App More info

Features

Easy installation
Automatic order fulfillment
Cheapest usps pricing
Pre-negotiated ups rates
No fees or markups
Best shipping rates
Pay-as-you-go postage
Print carrier labels

Protected checkout experience
Full coverage orders
Prompt refunds/reorders
Boost revenue
Smart tech support
2-minute claims resolution
Revenue sharing

Screenshots

Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping screenshot

+ 7 more

ShipInsure Shipping Protection screenshot

+ 2 more

Your request is being processed and will be delivered shortly. If you do not receive an email from Taranker within the next 5 minutes, please check your spam folder and mark it as "Not Spam" to ensure future emails reach your inbox.

Pros

Offers the cheapest USPS pricing tier available, BELOW Commercial Pricing for Priority Mail
Provides pre-negotiated UPS rates with no fees or markup
Users pay only the actual cost of the postage
Includes secret services like Priority Mail Cubic for additional savings
Easy to install and use, allowing shipping to start in seconds
Provides best shipping rates for all USPS and UPS services
Supports various payment methods including credit, debit card, and PayPal
Compatible with both desktop and label printers for printing labels
Automatically marks Shopify orders as 'Fulfilled' and adds tracking numbers

Provides peace of mind from checkout to delivery
Full coverage for lost, damaged, or stolen orders
More than half of shoppers opt for the service, enhancing the purchasing experience
Prompt refunds or reorder process in the rare event of an issue
No cost to the merchant for the service
Decrease in customer support time and costs using smart tech, AI, and a skilled team
Minimizes losses and boosts revenue through order protection
2-minute claims resolution increases customer lifetime value
Option for merchants to choose their own pricing and revenue share

Cons

Limited to USPS and UPS, restricting other carrier options
Potential learning curve for users unfamiliar with label printing
Relies on external payment methods which may have their own processing times

Potential dependency on the app for customer satisfaction and order protection
Merchants may need to handle the logistics of reorders

Launched

Jul 10, 2017

Sep 09, 2021

Developer

Built by Pirate Ship

Apps:

Average Rating:

3.7

Reviews:

Built by ShipInsure

Apps:

Average Rating:

3.7

Reviews:

Make Your Choice

Install App More info View alternatives

Install App More info

Related blog

Top 14 Fulfilling Orders Apps in 2025 for Shopify to Streamline Your Shipping Process

Compare Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping vs ShipInsure Shipping Protection

Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping

ShipInsure Shipping Protection

Pirate Ship: CheapARR Shipping