Pfand vs PWYW: Best Shopify App Comparison

Compare Pfand Deposit vs. Pay What You Want Shopify apps for fees, flexibility, and customer engagement. Find the right app for your store today!

Are you looking to optimize your Shopify store with the right fee-handling or pricing strategy but unsure which app—Pfand Deposit & Cart Fee or Pay What You Want (PWYW)—suits your needs best? In this comprehensive comparison, we'll explore the features, benefits, and potential drawbacks of each application, focusing on how they can enhance your Shopify experience. Whether you're aiming to boost customer engagement or streamline your checkout process, this guide will provide you with valuable insights to help you make an informed decision tailored to your business goals.

View More View Less

Pfand - Deposit & Cart Fee

Create Mandatory / Opt Fees, Deposit & Surcharge + Many more.

Pay What You Want ‑ PWYW

Offer easy donation & make an offer with better price bargain

Pfand - Deposit & Cart Fee

Create Mandatory / Opt Fees, Deposit & Surcharge + Many more.

Pay What You Want ‑ PWYW

Offer easy donation & make an offer with better price bargain

Rating

25 Reviews

5.4

52 Reviews

9.1

Pricing

More info

Install App More info

Features

Mandatory/optional fees
Fixed/percentage fees
Pos/online integration
Conditional fee application
Return fee support
Bundle fee handling
Cash rounding

Theme compatibility
Dynamic pricing flexibility
Price range limits
Customer-named pricing
Make an offer option
Easy donation process
Direct checkout shortcuts

Screenshots

+ 7 more

+ 2 more

Your request is being processed and will be delivered shortly. If you do not receive an email from Taranker within the next 5 minutes, please check your spam folder and mark it as "Not Spam" to ensure future emails reach your inbox.

Pros

Allows creation of both mandatory and optional fees
Supports both fixed price and percentage-based fees
Can be used online, POS, or both
Fees can be applied based on various conditions like product type, cart total, customer, and location
Supports returning fees to customers for returned items
Compatible with product bundles
Supports cash rounding
Ability to apply fees per product quantity

Increases sales by offering dynamic pricing
Helps reduce cart abandonment caused by fixed prices
Allows customers to name their price, which can improve purchase decisions
Compatible with all free and premium themes
Encourages loyalty programs and easy donations
Includes features to set price limits and redirect users directly from catalog to Cart or Checkout page

Cons

Complexity in setting up the various conditions and rules for fees
Potential for customer dissatisfaction with mandatory fees
May require training for staff to use effectively, especially in POS settings
Additional overhead for managing fees and ensuring they are applied correctly

May result in lower profit margins as customers could pay less than expected
Potentially higher administrative or customer service burden managing offers and negotiations
Could create customer confusion or dissatisfaction if price expectations are not met
Requires careful management and monitoring to ensure offers are reasonable and sustainable for the business

Launched

Mar 28, 2025

Developer

Built by Shopify

Apps:

960

Average Rating:

3.3

Reviews:

46,437

Built by Extendons

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.3

Reviews:

608

Make Your Choice

More info

Install App More info View alternatives

Pfand vs PWYW: Best Shopify App Comparison

Pfand - Deposit & Cart Fee

Pay What You Want ‑ PWYW

Pfand - Deposit & Cart Fee

Pay What You Want ‑ PWYW

Rating

Rating

Pricing

Pricing

Features

Features

Screenshots

Screenshots

Send this compare to my inbox

Pros

Pros

Cons

Cons

Categories

Categories

Launched

Launched

Developer

Developer

Built by Shopify

Built by Extendons

Make Your Choice

Make Your Choice