Magical vs Offerly: Best Shopify Make an Offer Apps

Name: Offerly: Make an Offer Button!
Brand: Nakatomi Apps

Are you considering enhancing your Shopify store with a 'Make an Offer' feature and trying to decide between the Magical Make an Offer and Offerly Make an Offer Button apps? In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll break down the key aspects of both apps, including features, pricing, user interface, and customer support, to help you determine which app aligns best with your business goals. Whether you're just starting out or looking to boost your ecommerce strategy, our analysis will guide you in selecting the ideal app to optimize customer interactions and increase sales on your Shopify store.

Magical Make an Offer

Add Best Offer + Pay What you Want Buttons to Sell More Stuff.

Offerly: Make an Offer Button!

Increase sales by accepting offers or bids on your products!

Magical Make an Offer

Add Best Offer + Pay What you Want Buttons to Sell More Stuff.

Offerly: Make an Offer Button!

Increase sales by accepting offers or bids on your products!

Rating

172 Reviews

9.1

48 Reviews

Pricing

Install App More info

Features

Customizable messages
Custom fields
Exit popups
Set pricing rules
Best offer button
Pay what you want

Customizable pop-up
Customizable emails
Make an offer button
Automated response rules
Manual negotiation
Strategic pricing insights
Increased sales

Screenshots

+ 6 more

Offerly: Make an Offer Button! screenshot

+ 1 more

Your request is being processed and will be delivered shortly. If you do not receive an email from Taranker within the next 5 minutes, please check your spam folder and mark it as "Not Spam" to ensure future emails reach your inbox.

Pros

Allows flexible negotiation through Best Offer and Pay What You Want options
Automated accept, decline, or counteroffer rules simplify price negotiations
Increases chances of a successful sale by inviting buyer engagement
Customizable messages and style to fit your brand
Exit popups to encourage customers to make an offer
Option to add custom fields to enhance negotiation or collect required details
Positive customer support experience, as mentioned in reviews

Provides customers the opportunity to name their own price, increasing engagement and potential sales
Supports automation for responding to offers, including auto-accept, auto-decline, and auto-counter features
Customization options available for pop-ups and emails to fit the branding of the store
Helps merchants discover strategic pricing insights
Reportedly excellent customer support for setup and customization
Effective for niche markets like Art, Vintage, and Collectables stores
Quick issue resolution based on user feedback (eg, display issues fixed within 24 hours)
Highly positive user reviews indicating satisfaction with service, functionality, and support

Cons

Potential for lower offers impacting overall profitability
Requires careful setting of rules to avoid unwanted low offers
Customization may require additional customer support or technical skills

Newer app with fewer reviews, which may deter early adopters looking for more robust social proof
Potential minor display issues, although these seem to be resolved quickly by the support team

Launched

Nov 05, 2015

Jan 23, 2024

Developer

Built by Magical Apps

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.8

Reviews:

601

Built by Nakatomi Apps

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.8

Reviews:

Make Your Choice

Install App More info View alternatives

Install App More info

Related blog

Top 14 Shopify Custom Pricing & Quote Apps 2025 to Personalize Offers & Close More Sales

Magical vs Offerly: Best Shopify Make an Offer Apps

Magical Make an Offer

Offerly: Make an Offer Button!

Magical Make an Offer