Magical vs ACF: Best Custom Fields for Shopify

Compare Magical Custom Fields & Upload vs ACF Metafields for Shopify. Uncover the best app for your store's needs!

Are you a Shopify store owner looking to enhance your store's functionality with custom fields and metafields, but unsure whether to choose Magical Custom Fields & Upload or ACF + Metafields Custom Fields? In this comprehensive comparison, we'll explore the key features, ease of use, integration capabilities, and pricing of both Shopify apps. Whether you're new to adding custom fields or seeking to optimize your store's data management, this guide will help you make an informed decision to enhance your store's customization and user experience.

View Less

Magical Custom Fields & Upload

Add Custom Form Fields to Products and Checkout Extensions

ACF: Metafields Custom Fields

View, create, edit, export & import your custom metafields

Magical Custom Fields & Upload

Add Custom Form Fields to Products and Checkout Extensions

ACF: Metafields Custom Fields

View, create, edit, export & import your custom metafields

Rating

67 Reviews

9.1

120 Reviews

8.5

Pricing

Install App More info

Features

File upload
Product page customization
Image upload
Conditional fields
Style customization
Add form fields
Flexible field rules
Collect order details

File uploads
Color picker
Csv export
Create metafields
Date & time
View metafields
Edit metafields
Export metafields
Import metafields
Bulk management
Filter metafields
Search metafields
References support
Json support
Text support
Liquid syntax retrieval

Screenshots

Magical Custom Fields & Upload screenshot

+ 6 more

ACF: Metafields Custom Fields screenshot

+ 2 more

Your request is being processed and will be delivered shortly. If you do not receive an email from Taranker within the next 5 minutes, please check your spam folder and mark it as "Not Spam" to ensure future emails reach your inbox.

Pros

Easy way to build and manage order form fields
Add product form fields to product pages or the cart at checkout
Allows customization of orders and personalization of products
Offers a variety of form field options such as Text Field, Image Upload, File Upload, Checkboxes, Terms & Conditions, Gift Wrapping, Gift Message, Special Requests, etc
Flexible rules to add fields to specific products, variants, or collections
Can help in collecting additional information from customer orders
Conditional fields feature to show or hide options based on other field values
Support is very speedy and professional

Simplifies metafield management by enabling manual or bulk handling
Supports various data types including color pickers, date & time, files, references, JSON, and text
Allows easy viewing, filtering, searching, and editing of metafields
Offers importing and exporting of metafields in different formats, including CSV
Supports file uploads for storing and presenting custom data
Allows retrieval of liquid syntax for incorporating custom data
Enables creating, updating, and deleting metafields in bulk

Cons

Limited logic possible with fields that are managed outside the app
Certain form fields cannot be made required based on external factors like shipping method

Could be complex for users unfamiliar with metafields or custom data management
No indication of customer support or help resources availability
Might require significant time to set up for extensive use cases
Limited information on integration with other systems or platforms
Potential performance issues with large datasets due to bulk operations

Launched

Mar 28, 2025

Developer

Built by Magical Apps

Apps:

Average Rating:

4.8

Reviews:

1,071

Built by ArenaCommerce

Apps:

Average Rating:

3.3

Reviews:

153

Make Your Choice

Install App More info View alternatives

Magical vs ACF: Best Custom Fields for Shopify

Magical Custom Fields & Upload

ACF: Metafields Custom Fields

Magical Custom Fields & Upload

ACF: Metafields Custom Fields

Rating

Rating

Pricing

Pricing

Features

Features

Screenshots

Screenshots

Send this compare to my inbox

Pros

Pros

Cons

Cons

Categories

Categories

Launched

Launched

Developer

Developer

Built by Magical Apps

Built by ArenaCommerce

Make Your Choice

Make Your Choice